Pages

Wednesday, 2 October 2013

Basketcase Derby should be grateful to Clough! He saved them... and now it's time for McClaren to really kick on.

When the world of English football reacts with surprise to a managerial change, it stands to reason that factors other than results have come into play.
And that certainly appears to be the case with Nigel Clough.
True, he had experienced a bad week. True, progress was slow. True also, there was a perception among supporters that he played negative football.
On his way: Nigel Clough was sacked by Derby County after defeat at Nottingham Forest
On his way: Nigel Clough was sacked by Derby County after defeat at Nottingham Forest

Unfortunate: Clough could have been given more time at Pride Park
Unfortunate: Clough could have been given more time at Pride Park

But it was also an undeniable fact to say that Clough took over a basketcase of a football club at a very difficult time.
He had to strip it back, start again and rebuild from within while also retaining Derby County’s status in the Championship. That was the minimum. It was achieved. And then some.
Now you could say that five years is ample time to see such a return.
You may say that trying to work within a budget that dropped from £15.9m to a figure of roughly half that does not present an insurmountable barrier to success.
You may even discount the chronic injury problems with which the Rams had to deal at certain times during Clough Jnr’s reign.
But what no-one can deny is that Derby County is in a far better place now than it was when Clough assumed control.
The playing staff is stronger. For the first time in almost a generation, the Rams have saleable assets out on that luscious green turf.
Will Hughes, Jeff Hendrick and Craig Bryson are three that could be sold to realise a profit. The sale of John Brayford, another Clough import, generated sufficient funds for the manager’s work this summer to pay for itself.
No longer is Derby County seen as a basketcase. The Academy is producing. Clough was prepared to give youth its’ head. How old was Mason Bennett again?
Acted quickly: Steve McClaren was in place before the draw against Ipswich
Acted quickly: Steve McClaren was in place before the draw against Ipswich

The problem, such as it was, is that the new chief executive Sam Rush has a different take on matters.
He is trying to work out why it is that the likes of West Bromwich Albion, defeated just six years ago in the play-off final at Wembley, have overtaken the Rams.
He believes that the system and team that has been put together - now that Steve McClaren has been put in charge - is one that can deliver results.
He says it’s not all about the money - and that Clough had cash to spend last summer that was not used.
Pressure: Chief Executive Sam Rush (right) has his eyes set on a Premier League return
Pressure: Chief Executive Sam Rush (right) has his eyes set on a Premier League return

Rush is trying to find a way to bridge the gap. He talked about an improvement in the scouting and recruitment, in football 'relationships'.
The first two are self-explanatory. The latter concerns being able to pick up the phone to a manager of one of the big six and being able to loan a youngster who might make a big difference in the Championship.
Rush is looking at other systems that are workable. And trying to gain what everyone in the Championship seeks - that competitive edge.
Genius: The likes of Brian Clough won't be seen again
Genius: The likes of Brian Clough won't be seen again

The problem was that Clough came from a background where the manager’s voice is generally the only one that was heard.
I didn’t have the ‘pleasure’ of working directly with his father, but in my humble opinion, working alongside Peter Taylor, Clough Snr was a managerial untouchable. A genius.
To take two provincial clubs to league titles, to win the European Cup twice and take the other to the semi-final was...well, we will never see his like again.
But Clough Snr did it very much on his own terms. A bully? By the sounds of it, on occasion. But if you speak with the likes of John McGovern, Trevor Francis or Martin O’Neill, they will accede to the twin merits of his force of personality and his methods.
Consequently, his son resisted any attempt previously to bring in a director of football. He won that battle 18 months ago.
But Rush was a new man. He has his own pressures. He has recently been appointed to the post of chief executive. His neck will be on the block if Derby do not progress.
He has his own ideas - clearly too he had a replacement in mind when the axe fell following the defeat at the City Ground. The search was ‘well underway’ within two hours of the news breaking. ‘Well underway’? After two hours of looking. Come on, pull the other one.
New team: McClaren and Rush stand with coaches Paul Simpson (left) and Eric Steele (second from right)
New team: McClaren and Rush stand with coaches Paul Simpson (left) and Eric Steele (second from right)

And Rush has a system in mind for the football side of the business. For what it’s worth now - right now - I think it could work.
McClaren is a respected coach. Not yet in last-chance saloon as a manager in his own right. But certainly in need of a club like Derby County.
Paul Simpson, who has also tasted life in the managerial hot-seat, should provide sensible support. Eric Steele worked with the best. At heart, a Derby man.
It’s a solid team. Looks good on paper. With a solid director of football to hold the purse strings and organise the recruitment, it could work.
And to McClaren’s credit, he accentuated all the positives at his unveiling. How Nigel had left an exciting legacy. He was generous - but then it wasn’t his decision to sack the outgoing man.
Miss: Clough was hampered by captain Shaun Barker's long-term injury problems
Miss: Clough was hampered by captain Shaun Barker's long-term injury problems

Of course, Derby’s supporters - on my patch they are more fair-minded than most - showed their appreciation for him taking on a difficult job with their applause in the ninth minute during that game against Ipswich.
Personally, I think Clough Jnr should have been given a bit more time this season.
We are, after all, only two months into a new campaign.
Off the pitch, for the media, he was a dream. Polite, punctual, quotable. Traits that are always going to win him a few friends.
On it, Clough struggled with injuries. Shaun Barker’s absence robbed him of a key figure both on the pitch and inside the dressing-room.
Though he nurtured midfield talents, he could never quite find the striker that would score the 20-plus goals needed to turn a decent side into a good one.
Homely: Former Rams winger Paul Simpson (right) has been appointed assistant manager
Homely: Former Rams winger Simpson (right) has been appointed assistant manager

He probably needed a tad more time. He was one signing away from possibly turning Derby into play-off challengers.
But in the end, time was the one commodity he ran out of. Caught in a perfect storm with a new boss in a hurry and a suitable replacement waiting in the wings.
However, history will show that Clough made sense of the madness at a difficult time for Derby County Football Club.
And if the new incumbent succeeds in the next couple of years, I do hope it’s remembered that Nigel Clough played a significant part in it.

Clubs offered money to me then went back on their word... these are the real world struggles players outside the Premier League face.

I was panicking right through the summer until I finally signed for Leicester City in September. If you haven't got a club there are no wages coming in. There are bills to pay. You've got to try and remain positive and keep your fitness up as best you can while waiting for that call.
It was a huge relief to get underway for my new club.
The whole episode was so frustrating. At the end of last season Blackpool made me an offer I didn't agree with. It was under their terms and I didn't want to sign it.
It was all about trying to get someone to commit to the right deal. The security is more important than the money coming in. I spoke to Blackpool a few times and tried to get it towards my favour a little more. The way they word the options is that at the end of the year you have to have a pay cut.
Back so soon: Gary Taylor-Fletcher made his Leicester debut at Blackpool
Back so soon: Gary Taylor-Fletcher made his Leicester debut at Blackpool

   
I was trying to get them to change it so that when I played so many games I automatically get the same deal. They wouldn't have that, but at Leicester I've managed to secure it.
They have faith in me. If I play those games I get an extra year. That was a big point for me. 
A lot of clubs were interested in me but needed to sell players first. It was disappointing not to have a club during the first weekend of the season. I was thinking that I should be out there playing.
Sheffield Wednesday, Charlton and Millwall rang me to go down and train with them for a week. They basically said, 'We've got this contract offer for you but want to see you train'. 
When arriving there the offer ends up being less than they've originally said or agreed. It seemed to be like that all the time.
They say we've got this amount of money available. Chairmen then change their minds, managers get under pressure. Things change and that's happened to me quite a bit. Unfortunately it was during a summer when Financial Fair Play came in. A lot of clubs are using that to their advantage.
They're offering less and can't afford what they thought they could.
The power is coming back to the clubs a little bit. They're trying to balance the books a bit more. A few seasons ago they'd take a risk for a year or two and really push the boat out to try to get promoted to the promised land of the Premier League.
Chairmen are getting a bit wary now. Can they overspend? I don't think they can any more. 
The clubs will hold more power. It'll start to even out.
Thankfully Leicester have always been honest. They needed to move players on but remained interested. I got the call, came in and it went from there.
I had four weeks with Sheffield Wednesday and a week each with Charlton and Millwall. I've had a good six weeks training football-wise, but it's the matches you miss.
The worst thing was that I missed the first two weeks of proper pre-season running. It does take a long time to get that back in your legs.
I've played in the Conference and the lower leagues and wouldn't be afraid to do that again. If someone wants to pay me to play, I'll do it.
Ready: Taylor-Fletcher admitted he has struggled for fitness after missing the first fortnight of pre-season
Ready: Taylor-Fletcher admitted he has struggled for fitness after missing the first fortnight of pre-season

My rise was unbelievable. I was 17, at college, and playing pub football. I was doing my A-levels, did well for the college team and got into England Schools.
They said to me that I needed to be playing at a better level and to look after myself.
I was playing the proper Holland Under 18s. So I rang Northwich Victoria up to ask if I could play for their youth team. I played two games for them and was promoted to the first team.
Big break: Taylor-Fletcher's career began to take off at Lincoln City in 2003
Big break: Taylor-Fletcher's career began to take off at Lincoln City in 2003

Stepping stones: Huddersfield signed the then-midfielder on a free transfer
Stepping stones: Huddersfield signed the then-midfielder on a free transfer

Indebted: Taylor-Fletcher talks of the impact Keith Alexander had on his career
Indebted: Taylor-Fletcher talks of the impact Keith Alexander had on his career

From there it took off. Keith Alexander came in and gave me my big chance. I can't thank him enough. In the first 20 games I scored 16 goals. A few clubs were interested and Stoke City put an offer in for me.
Northwich didn't want to sell me, but I went on loan to Hull. That was a really good experience to see what it was like to be a full-time footballer. I was only used to two nights a week.
I then didn't have the best of times at Leyton Orient after signing for them. I didn't really fit before Alexander took me to Lincoln. He really believed in me.
Once I got to Lincoln that was it. 
Every two years I took a stepping stone and proved that I could do it in each division. I went to Huddersfield in League One and then Blackpool bought me when they were promoted to the Championship in 2007.
It was 10 years before I got to that level but I had to prove to myself that I was good enough. When we got to the Premier League it was one of those.
Oh my God: are we going to get battered every week? Are we going to get the lowest points ever?
Dive! Enjoying his time at Huddersfield, Taylor-Fletcher celebrates equalising against Chelsea in the FA Cup at Stamford Bridge
Dive! Enjoying his time at Huddersfield, Taylor-Fletcher celebrates equalising against Chelsea in the FA Cup at Stamford Bridge (above) and chases down Eidur Gudjohnsen

GTF

In the end I surprised myself when playing at the top. You could tell the real top-class players were head and shoulders above, but against everyone else I felt I was just as good. I deserved to be there. Doing the double over Liverpool - my boyhood team - was magnificent.
It was only one year but nobody can take that away from me. I realised my dream. When you get told as a young lad that you're not good enough you doubt yourself. The journey I had meant I had a bit more determination than others. I was always having to prove myself.
Take off: He continued to rise through the divisions with Blackpool
Take off: He continued to rise through the divisions with Blackpool

Top flight: Promotion to the Premier League in 2010 saw Taylor-Fletcher realise his dream
Top flight: Promotion to the Premier League in 2010 saw Taylor-Fletcher realise his dream

Highlight: He scored for Blackpool at Old Trafford the day they were relegated
Highlight: Taylor-Fletcher scored for Blackpool at Old Trafford but admitted his time at the club had gone stale

Sometimes when you're at a club for a long time you go a bit stale. That happened to me at Blackpool. I needed a freshness. That was the main reason for wanting to get away. I was saying to my wife recently that I've got that hunger back. That's helping me.
It's not too late to play in the Premier League again. We've got a good squad here and we're aiming for promotion. This is a massive club. I didn't realise that until I got here.
You have seen rises similar to mine happen a lot more recently. Dwight Gayle at Crystal Palace is the latest to do it. If you're good enough and you believe in yourself there is always a chance.
On the up: Dwight Gayle has had a similar rise from non-League to Premier League
On the up: Dwight Gayle has had a similar rise from non-League to Premier League

Football is changing in that respect down the leagues. But you look at the Premier League and the money bandied about for English players. Getting anyone homegrown is ridiculous.
You look at Tom Ince at Blackpool - who is an absolutely magnificent player - and only one club, Cardiff, went in for him. Most would rather go for a foreign import. That needs to change.
They could be scared off by the fee but a lot of the foreign managers are changing the mentality. The Premier League is thriving from it but England have struggled as a result.
Where we go now depends on what the authorities do about it. You might have to limit the number of foreign players or have an English quota.
Missed opportunity: Taylor-Fletcher can't understand why Cardiff were the only side to bid for Tom Ince
Missed opportunity: Taylor-Fletcher can't understand why Cardiff were the only side to bid for Tom Ince (centre)

We only enjoy short careers. The money that's knocking around in the Premier League is astronomical, but in the lower leagues you don't get as much money as people think.
Only the Premier League players and possibly the top lads in the Championship - who have played in the top flight for a few years - won't have to work after retirement.

The rest of us will need to get a job and do something after football. You have to think about that. You've taken 15 years out of your life doing something you love.
At 32, I've got to start planning.

Holloway
Pearson
After you, boss: The forward is looking to follow Ian Holloway and Nigel Pearson into management

I'm doing my coaching badges at the moment would like to stay in the game. I'm on my Uefa B licence and will finish that before the summer so I can go straight on to my A.

It gives you more opportunity. I want to be a manager. I know a lot of players who have been at clubs that sacked their managers and have had the chance of taking over.

Give me another three or four years and if a job does become available I'll be pushing myself to go for it.

Meet the Championship's surprise package: Dyche's merry bunch at Burnley who are keeping QPR off the top (for now at least)

They didn't spend a penny over the summer, but Burnley are the side keeping Harry Redknapp's Queens Park Rangers off the top of the Championship table - for now at least.
The Clarets are sitting pretty after ten games - the usual parameter to indicate how a season might pan out - with Sean Dyche lauded as one of the best young managers outside the Premier League.
QPR lie in second and have a game in hand over the Lancashire side and could leapfrog them should they beat Wigan at the end of the month, but that takes nothing away from Burnley's blistering start.
Not exactly trapped: Sean Dyche is enjoying life at Burnley, who sit top of the Championship
Not exactly trapped: Sean Dyche is enjoying life at Burnley, who sit top of the Championship

Not many people outside Turf Moor envisaged the club challenging, especially given the lack of finance afforded to Dyche in the close season.
Only Watford have scored more. Only QPR have conceded less.
It is a Burnley squad almost entirely revamped from their brief flirtation with the top flight four years ago. After using the Premier League riches and subsequent parachute payments on restructuring their hefty debts, the club were never able to truly kick on from their year in the sun.
Barry Kilby, chairman of 13 years, stepped down just over a year ago through ill health. Mike Garlick and John Banaszkiewicz were appointed to take his place and under Dyche's stewardship - with an effective brand of football - the Clarets have become a surprise package. 
And they look below at everyone else - for 24 hours at least - after a comfortable 2-0 win at Doncaster Rovers.
Surprise: The Clarets weren't expected to be challenging for promotion but have lost just once
Surprise: The Clarets weren't expected to be challenging for promotion but have lost just once

Smoking! Burnley supporters can scarcely believe their upturn after last year's upheaval
Smoking! Burnley supporters can scarcely believe their upturn after last year's upheaval

All this despite selling their best player in each of the last four campaigns. This summer it was the turn of Charlie Austin to seek pastures new - sold, ironically, to Redknapp's QPR for £4million.
It was left to Danny Ings - signed by former boss Eddie Howe in 2011 - to shoulder the responsibility of replacing Austin's 28 goals. The ex-Bournemouth man hasn't made a bad start.
Only Huddersfield's James Vaughan has notched more than Ings' ten, while the 21-year-old's partner up front, Sam Vokes, has seven as well.
So what does the make-up of this squad look like? Sportsmail has all you need to know about the Burnley contingent who could continue to shock a few.
Pairing: Sam Vokes (left) and Danny Ings have been on fire so far this season and softening the blow of losing Charlie Austin to QPR
Pairing: Sam Vokes (left) and Danny Ings have been on fire so far this season and softening the blow of losing Charlie Austin to QPR

 

Jason Shackell

Cost: Undisclosed (Estimate: £1.1m)
Signed from: Derby
One of the few players Burnley have actually spent money on in the last two years, Shackell is a solid central defender. Isn't part of the new breed who like the ball at their feet, but does his job and does it well.
In there somewhere: Jason Shackell's rugged displays are crucial to Burnley's backbone
In there somewhere: Jason Shackell's rugged displays are crucial to Burnley's backbone

Michael Kightly

Cost: Loan
From: Stoke City
Injury curtailed a Premier League career that had looked as if it may take off. Kightly never looked the same after a collection of long-term injuries suffered at Wolves, and East Lancashire is providing the perfect platform for the winger to rediscover the sort of form that saw him talked about as one of the best young prospects in the country.
Starting again: Michael Kightly is trying to get his career back on track under Dyche
Starting again: Michael Kightly is trying to get his career back on track under Dyche

Michael Duff

Cost: £30,000
From: Cheltenham

The lower divisions are full of bargains, but very few have represented better value for money than Duff. The defender cost a pittance in 2004 and has been with the club ever since. A rock at the back and still playing consistently at the grand old age of 35.
Seen it all: Michael Duff is one of very few survivors from the Premier League season in 2009/10
Seen it all: Michael Duff is one of very few survivors from the Premier League season in 2009/10

Sam Vokes

Cost: Undisclosed (Estimate: £300,000)

From: Wolves

Possesses the physical attiributes to trouble any Championship defence, Vokes is an excellent tool to have in the bag. Hasn't been prolific up until this season. Impressively, of his seven goals so far, four have been winners. At 23, the Welsh international has plenty yet to give.
Finding his feet: Sam Vokes has started to hit the back of the net more often this season
Finding his feet: Sam Vokes has started to hit the back of the net more often this season

David Jones

Cost: Free

From: Wigan Athletic

Jones might have played for bitter rivals Blackburn Rovers on loan last year, but the opportunity to snap the midfielder up on a free was too good to miss. With a cultured left foot, the desire to put his foot in and versatility, Jones is an useful option to have.

Kieran Trippier 

Cost: Undisclosed
From: Manchester City
One of the most sought-after full-backs outside the Premier League and clubs are keeping tabs on his progression. Signed for the club in 2012 after a successful loan spell and gives much-needed energy down the right hand side. A near ever-present last season and has continued in the same vein.
Outlet: Kieran Trippier likes to get forward as much as possible and was integral during the win at Doncaster
Outlet: Kieran Trippier likes to get forward as much as possible and was integral during the win at Doncaster

Tom Heaton

Cost: Free 
From: Bristol City

Although released by relegated Bristol City in the summer, Heaton has plenty of Championship experience. The ex-Man United goalkeeper has also played for Cardiff City and is having one of his best ever spells between the sticks - conceding just five league goals.

Danny Ings

Cost: Undisclosed (Estimate: £900,000) 
From: Bournemouth
The next big thing to be nurtured at Burnley. Six goals in the league and four in the Capital One Cup have seen the 21-year-old quickly rise to prominence. Ings suffered a serious knee injury which kept him out for half of the 2012/13 season, but he's showing a knack in front of goal that will have top flight vultures circling.
Regular: Danny Ings has scored 10 goals in all competitions already this season
Regular: Danny Ings has scored 10 goals in all competitions already this season

Scott Arfield

Cost: Free
From: Huddersfield Town

A busy attacking midfielder, the Scot is capable of floating in behind the strikers to good effect. Had appeared to be going nowhere at Huddersfield before being released on a free transfer, but Dyche is managing to get the best out of the 24-year-old. A perfect example of the type of cheap player available in the Championship that can be polished.
Gamble? Scott Arfield was released by Huddersfield but has quickly bedded in at Burnley
Gamble? Scott Arfield was released by Huddersfield but has quickly bedded in at Burnley

Junior Stanislas

Cost: Undisclosed (Estimate: £500,000)
From: West Ham United
Very much a direct runner who likes to beat a man, Stanislas could prove to be a steal for the Clarets. One to watch when at West Ham but failed to produce consistently enough, although still only 23.

Dean Marney

Cost: £500,000
From: Hull City
Perhaps Burnley's biggest signing immediately after dropping out of the Premier League in 2010, Marney has gone on to make more than 100 appearances for the club. Chips in with a few goals from midfield, takes set pieces and is tough tackling when he needs to be.
Impact: Dean Marney, now 29, burst on to the scene when a youngster at Tottenham
Impact: Dean Marney, now 29, burst on to the scene when a youngster at Tottenham

Ross Wallace

Cost: £500,000
From: Preston North End

Another to be captured after going down in 2010, Wallace made the switch from Lancashire rivals Preston. The Scotland international is considered to be one of Burnley's more important attacking outlets - although supporters claim he could offer more - but is out of action for a number of months with a knee problem.

David Edgar

Cost: £300,000
From: Newcastle United
Nearing 100 appearances for the club since a move from Newcastle four years ago. Played the majority of last season under Howe and Dyche, and the Canadian has been used by the latter this.

Ben Mee

Cost: Undisclosed
From: Manchester City
Nothing spectacular but reliable at the back, Mee is the sort of dependable defender needed during a long, hard season in the second tier and coming into his own under Dyche's guidance.
Product: Ben Mee came from the Manchester City academy and is beginning to establish himself in the Championship
Product: Ben Mee came from the Manchester City academy and is beginning to establish himself at Turf Moor

Spot-kick stats! With Leicester on five penalties in five games (with Nugent scoring SIX this season), your guide to the stunning records from the spot

After Leicester were awarded their fifth penalty in five straight games – and David Nugent scored his sixth of the season – Sportsmail celebrates the weird and wonderful penalty stats.
The Foxes have started the Championship season excellently, and it could finally be their year to return to the Premier League.
But how do Nugent and Leicester's bizarre relationship with spot-kicks compare to their top flight counterparts? We have team and player stats for you to get your teeth into.
Routine: David Nugent has converted SIX penalties already this season
Routine: David Nugent has converted SIX penalties already this season

 

Team to score the most penalties in a season - Crystal Palace


The Eagles were handed 13 penalties during their relegation season - converting 11 of them.
Andy Johnson was the main protagonist for earning the spot-kicks, continually hauled down in the box, and scored all of them
It's a good job Johnson was so lethal from 12 yards that season, because less than half of his goals came from open play.
Safe: Andy Johnson scored all 11 of Crystal Palace's goals from the spot in the 2004/05 season
Safe: Andy Johnson scored all 11 of Crystal Palace's goals from the spot in the 2004/05 season

a

 

Player with the best success rate - Leighton Baines

The Southampton forward was renowned for his ability from the penalty spot and famously only ever missed one throughout his entire career. 
Everton's Leighton Baines is the real winner, though, having never failed. There is still time yet and the left-back has only taken 10 penalties, but is 100 per cent record is certainly not to be sniffed at.

Winner: Leighton Baines has never missed a penalty in the Premier League
Winner: Leighton Baines has never missed a penalty in the Premier League

Too easy: Matt Le Tissier only missed one penalty at Southampton
Too easy: Matt Le Tissier only missed one penalty at Southampton

a

 

What about the worst takers? Juan Pablo Angel heads the list...

Aston Villa striker Juan Pablo Angel didn't have an awful lot of luck - missing half of his Premier League penalties.
Wayne Rooney doesn't fare much better, scoring 14 of his 21, while Jonathan Walters' up and down season last year was compounded with spot-kick problems.
Surprisingly - for such a cool finisher - Kevin Phillips struggles in the list as well.
Fail: Juan Pablo Angel only scored five of his 10 penalties in England
Fail: Juan Pablo Angel only scored five of his 10 penalties in England

A

 

The team with the best conversion rate - Southampton

Admittedly it probably helps having Le Tissier and Rickie Lambert as main penalty takers during their time in the Premier League, but the Saints have always been proficient.
Scoring 96 per cent of 51 penalties is a super record, with Chelsea's 88 per cent from double the amount impressive as well.
Ironically the Foxes have a fairly poor conversion rate of 65 per cent in the top flight. But if Nugent and Co get there this season, who's to say that won't improve?
Not too shabby: Rickie Lambert has the penalty duty at Southampton
Not too shabby: Rickie Lambert has the penalty duty at Southampton

image001.png

image001.png

2012/13 history makers

Leicester may have been given six spot-kicks this year, but Tottenham and Swansea didn't win a single one last season.
It is the first time in Premier League history that more than one side hadn't been given one before.
Spurs seem to be making up for it this time around, with Roberto Soldado already notching twice from the spot.
No such worries: Tottenham have already scored two penalties so far this season
No such worries: Tottenham have already scored two penalties so far this season

Farce over Torres fails refs, players, fans... and football

In taking no action against Fernando Torres after his gouge and scratch on Tottenham Hotspur’s Jan Vertonghen, the FA have once again shown a complete lack of credibility.
We are asking an all-too-familiar question: is this body fit to rule over our national game?
Torres appeared to deliberately grab the Spurs defender’s face, sank his fingers into his flesh and dragged his nails across his cheek — all in front of an incredulous TV audience.

Ouch: Vertonghen pushes Torres away as the Spaniard grabs his face
Ouch: Vertonghen pushes Torres away as the Spaniard grabs his face

Torres keeps hold of Vertonghen's face

Chelsea's Fernando Torres (left) and Tottenham Hotspur's Jan Vertonghen have words

Angry: Vertonghen snarls at Torres who tries to laugh the incident off
Angry: Vertonghen snarls at Torres who tries to laugh the incident off

The FA rule

‘From the start of the 2013-14 campaign, where the referee’s view of an incident has been completely obstructed and the assistant referees or fourth official are not in a position to judge the challenge, The FA will be able to take retrospective action.
'This is not intended to usurp the authority of officials, who are best-placed to deal with incidents at the time they occur.’
In Monday’s Sportsmail, I called on the FA’s new review panel, set up to eradicate offences which are seen on TV but not by match officials, to act swiftly and decisively. What happened next? The  £50million Chelsea striker was let off on a technicality.
It was supposed to be the day we congratulated the FA for finally embracing common sense; for accepting that officials could not spot everything; for realising that using video evidence in such circumstances could add another layer to the judicial process.
Instead we are faced with farce. The FA’s official statement says no action could be taken because ‘one of the match officials saw the  coming together of the two players, albeit not in its entirety’.
Torres face grab
Torres face grab

Build up: Torres angers Vertonghen after tripping him up from behind
Build up: Torres angers Vertonghen after tripping him up from behind

What the fans had to say . . .

A selection from some of the hundreds of comments about Torres on MailOnline:
‘What a farcical and cowardly excuse from the FA, hiding behind their own policies (written by them) as usual’
- Dave, Cheadle

‘I saw it and it wasn’t that bad. He was smiling as he did it, and I don’t think it was particularly violent...rather disrespectful’
- Andy, Zurich

‘If this was Luis Suarez, all hell would have broken loose by now. FA have double standards’
- Sanjay, London

‘Do Chelsea have something on the FA? The ludicrous delay in pursuing Terry & the piddling punishment followed by the whitewashing of Torres’
- P Doff, York

‘How Torres has escaped a ban I’ll never know! That said, his second yellow was harsh. Poor showing all around from the FA’
- Super Stern, London

To have your say and tell Graham your view, leave a comment at the bottom of this article...
This conclusion was reached ‘in line with the FA’s policy on when retrospective action may be taken’.
A spiteful act of aggression is met with an FA fudge. From my experience and from reviewing the footage, it is clear that the closest official — the assistant referee — would have seen the players come together, but was unsighted when the gouging took place. Through no fault of his own, he could not have had the full details when making his split-second judgment.

So, what the official saw was an innocuous clash; what the TV viewers saw was a disgraceful attack. At that point the FA should have stepped in,  acting with authority and gaining credibility. Instead they have failed referees, players, fans and football.
Common sense tells anyone that Torres was guilty, but the FA hide behind some ludicrous self-imposed ruling that they cannot re-referee an incident which they feel an assistant referee ‘half-saw’.
If that is the case then how can they review incidents when a player has been sent off in the full view of a referee and overturn his decision and allow the player to escape  without suspension? As they did in the case of Vincent Kompany’s tackle on Jack Wilshere. If they are able to re-referee and correct errors, then they must also correct situations where the referee incorrectly fails to send a player off.
Did the fact that Torres was  dismissed, harshly or even in error later in the game, affect this decision? Did the presence of the ‘Special One’ make them lose their appetite in this case?
If the answer to either question is yes, they should hang their heads in shame.
The FA have also left themselves open to accusations of double standards. At the weekend, former Manchester United goalkeeper Peter Schmeichel drew comparisons with the Luis Suarez biting incident in April.


Gruesome: Peter Schmeichel said that Torres' scratch was as bad as Luis Suarez's bite on Branislav Ivanovic

Gruesome: Peter Schmeichel said that Torres' scratch was as bad as Luis Suarez's bite on Branislav Ivanovic


He told Match of the Day 2 Extra: ‘If Suarez had done that, people would have cried for another  10-game suspension. I see no  difference in biting a player and scratching a player. You cannot raise your hands in football.’
Suarez got a 10-match ban. Torres escaped without a scratch.
Football’s ruling body is in desperate need of an injection of credibility. A good starting point would be to sit down and change its laws so justice can be seen to be done.
Let off: Vincent Kompany escaped a ban after having his red card for this tackle on Jack Wilshere overturned
Let off: Vincent Kompany escaped a ban after having his red card for this tackle on Jack Wilshere overturned